(Tor Books, 464 pages)
Dark academia is at its best in Freya Marske’s latest novel, Bodies of Magic, a murder mystery that unfolds at the Academie of the Grand Duchy of Sieuxerr, where mage scholars have five years to learn how to master their healing powers and, at the end, five days to prove their knowledge and skills during a trial known as the Grand Exam.
The book takes place over the course of this trial, which brings together groups of five scholars who must work together to perform five real-life medical exams and possibly treat or heal their patients. The groups are assigned randomly, and it is a seemingly disparate group that happens upon a dead body right before their first case begins.
The body belongs to their classmate, Ysabel Caudotte, a high achiever and best friend of Clement Savoye, one of the five scholars who find her. It’s assumed by most at the Academie that Ysabel was burnt out and died by suicide, but the scholars who find her think otherwise. And so begins their quest to figure out who murdered her — while participating in the life-changing Grand Exam.
Along with Clement, the group includes Estiene, Alys, Moyna and Jehan, all of whom — of course — are carrying around their own secrets. We get each of their points of view throughout the book; one of the negatives, for me, is that the switch from character to character between chapters feels a little jarring, and sometimes it’s not clear right away whose point of view we’re getting, as the chapter headers do not name the characters.*
On the other hand, when I read books with shifting points of view I often find myself looking forward to the chapters of one character over another, but that was not the case here. Each character is interesting enough, and mysterious enough, that getting inside their heads feels like a gift and an answer.
Estiene’s father is a head healer and Estiene is forever trying not to let him down. Alys is rich and beautiful, but rumors abound that she offers favors for passing grades. Moyna doesn’t want to pass the exam because she doesn’t want the future that has been mapped out for her if she does. Jehan has gotten himself into some trouble that he’s hiding from everyone. And Clement is an introvert who’s mostly known for being Ysabel’s confidante.
None of them are friends prior to the Grand Exam, though there’s something going on between two of them that is masked with loathing (sincere loathing at times). The interactions between all of them gave me Breakfast Club vibes: A group of kids forced to spend a specific period of time together, who start out thinking they have nothing in common but develop an appreciation for each other, and their differences, as time goes on.
The world that Marske creates is compelling. It’s a fantasy for sure, but the reality of our modern-day healthcare system — and all the politics that go along with it — is there front and center. It turns out a world with magic isn’t enough to balance class discrepancies.
That being said, at no point did I feel like this message got in the way of the fantastical elements, the character relationships or the murder plot. The magic system is fascinating. Marske actually attended medical school, and has worked in hospitals and clinics, so there’s lived experience in these pages, alongside the superhuman healing.
Watching the scholars work together to figure out diagnoses for real patients based on their presenting symptoms and health history was genuinely intriguing. Each student has specific abilities and levels of healing power, and they can’t solve these cases on their own. They also can’t scheme and plot to find the answers behind Ysabel’s murder without each other. They’re tethered together, for better or for worse.
Despite the book being about students attending school, this is not a YA novel. It almost could be, but these are college-age students figuring out life, so there are mature themes and some explicit sexual content.
But for adults — even those of us well past the college years — there’s a lot to like here. —Meghan Siegler A-
*As it turns out, I wasn’t being an attentive enough reader. In going back through the book for this review, I realized that the chapter headers do show us which character we’re hearing from — they’re just depicted by symbols rather than their names (a skull for Estiene, a candle for Clement, etc.). If I had figured that out, I think the transitions would have felt more fluid.
Featured Photo: Bodies of Magic by Freya Marske
