The Odyssey takes you on a journey with its nearly three-hour run time
Step 1 with watching Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey is to forget.
Like a lotus eater, forget stuff that came before — the barfy discourse around casting, what you think you remember from when you read (or skimmed or got someone to tell you the gist of) The Odyssey in school, what you think you remember about Greek myths in general (the movie explains whatever god or famous Greek-mythology human is at the core of a scene well enough for the purposes of watching the movie). And forget about the runtime, because yes, it’s long but the movie mostly uses those two hours and 50-some minutes pretty well and the pacing picks up right when it needs to. Also probably forget whatever your opinion is of Matt Damon, because the persona of Matt Damon is just going to get in the way of the performance the actor Matt Damon is giving. Ditto Anne Hathaway.
Just focus your viewing experience on the movie itself: the story of the nearly 20 years it takes Odysseus (Damon), king of Ithaca, to get back home to his wife, Penelope (Hathaway), and son Telemachus (Tom Holland), after having left for the Trojan War. We see different parts of this tale, from the beginning when Odysseus is explaining to Penelope why he has to participate in this sure-to-be quagmire-y endeavor and how much the war is going to suck, to the “guys in a horse” part to all the coming home stuff.
Though it’s not told linearly, the main action is roughly this: After 10 years, Agamemnon’s (Benny Safdie) dumb war is over and Odysseus decides instead of looting more from Troy and sailing straight back to Ithaca, they’ll pick up snacks along the way and “see a bit of the world,” a real “three-hour tour” plan that turns into a nearly decade-long trip. Along the way, Odysseus’ army and fleet of three ships meet a Cyclops (Bill Irwin); a witch named Circe (Samantha Morton); some sirens; some zombie soldiers; some armored giants and some supernaturally terrible weather. Each adventure takes a big bite out of the surviving number of Odysseus’s men and makes them both more desperate and less likely to ever reach their homes.
Meanwhile, back home, Penelope is trying to queen the country together but finds tensions high and civility fraying due in part to the many many suitors who have shown up at her castle to try to marry her. She has footed the bill for their years of feasting and drinking while they wait for her to decide to get married again. Telemachus suggests that he could be king, but Penelope points out that he can’t just say he’s the king, he needs everyone to buy in to the idea, which they aren’t right now without a definitive declaration of Odysseus’ death or proof that Telemachus is, essentially, grown up enough to hold the job.
That’s basically the action of the movie. The emotional “what it’s all about,” which becomes clearer as Odysseus works to remember, after years of living in a pleasant lotus buzz on an island with Calypso (Charlize Theron), who he is and what he needs to do, made me think of Nolan’s Oppenheimer. In some ways this movie feels like it is an expansion and examination of the philosophical question that ended that movie, with Oppenheimer worried that he had destroyed the world with the creation he spearheaded. When you’re stuck on a beach for 10 years trying to fight your way into a walled city or rushing to build a catastrophic weapon before a genocidal dictator can, you don’t always think about the long-term repercussions, if you are breaking something that can never be fixed, something that doesn’t just fight this fight but that, as Odyssesu puts it, wages war with civilization itself. That is Odysseus’ struggle, what he doesn’t know how to come back from.
This core struggle allows you to stay rooted in the story of this one family even when the movie brings in a massive cast of characters that range from a goddess (Zendaya) to the weaseliest of the suitors (Robert Pattinson). I never felt like I was getting lost in the spectacle of it all, though the spectacle of it all was mostly enjoyable to watch and I warmed to it over the course of the movie. The razzmatazz of angry Poseidon storms and huge armies on the march augments, not overwhelms, the human story.
The performances are all very good, even Hathaway’s, once I got over some “this is too thin for the Oscar nomination I’ll bet it earns” annoyance. And even Damon, once you let go of the fact that this guy just does not have a “king from antiquity” look or vibe about him, though I think that works for what the movie is trying to do. Everybody — every John Leguizamo and Lupita Nyong’o and Jon Bernthal body — adds a little something, pulls the overall narrative in an interesting little side direction. You could let that pull you out of the tale, but it could also put the story in its rightful place as something that is timeless, as in out-of-a-specific-time and more about the nature of humans than the historical events of the Bronze Age. This is not a history class; it’s a story, literal or metaphorical or somewhere in between, about a guy dealing with the world. And if you want to let your mind wander to the elements about our modern world that the movie seems to be commenting on, there are plenty of places where you can do that too.
(Extra credit; Before you see the movie, amp yourself up with The Odyssey: The Making of an Epic, a 22-minute docummercial on Peacock about the movie which delightfully nerds out about elements such as the on-location sets and the score.After, check out Vulture.com’s story “Christopher Nolan Explains the ‘Key’ to The Odyssey’s Ending,” in which they ask him more about the Oppenheimer-y nature of the movie — though when I thought about the Oppenheimer connection as I was leaving the movie, I didn’t particularly see it as a big reveal for either movie.)
I used Nolan’s The Odyssey as an excuse to check out The Return (streaming on Paramount+ and available for rent or purchase), a 2024 movie more tightly focused, as the title suggests, on Odysseus’ return to Ithaca. Here, broken down old man Odysseus (Ralph Fiennes) is fished out of the water near Ithaca only to be tossed back by some of Penelope’s (Juliette Binoche) suitors, who say there’s already enough of them and they hope he’ll just drown. Instead, he washes up naked on the shore and is tended to by Eumaeus (Claudio Santamaria), who explains how lousy things are on the island with remaining inhabitants at the mercy of the terrible suitors. They steal the livestock, they prey on the women and just generally they’re leading the island to ruin. Up at the castle, Odysseus’ son Telemachus (Charlie Plummer) is trying to keep from getting killed by the suitors and is almost convinced that his mom should just marry Antinous (Marwan Kenzari), the maybe least-awful of the bunch. As with Tom Holland’s Telemachus, Plummer’s Telemachus, as the movie begins, does not quite have the gravitas to take the throne for himself.
The Return is all scorched earth, all people trying to figure out if they can claw their way back from despair and violence. But quietly, without the spectacle of The Odyssey, The Return does its grief and frustration slower and at a lower volume. Which isn’t always to the movie’s benefit in terms of keeping this from being a downbeat slog. But Fiennes gives a solid performance and highlights the emotional struggles of Odysseus.
And speaking of stuff we read (or were at least assigned) in school, I also gave a watch to the 2026 Hamlet, which had a theatrical release in spring and is now available for rent or purchase. This adaptation stars Riz Ahmed as Hamlet, Morfydd Clark as Ophelia, Timothy Spall as Polonius, Sheeba Chaddha (maybe the MVP for me here?) as Gertrude, Joe Alwyn as Laertes and Art Malik as Claudius. Here, Elsinore is the big company that has made Hamlet’s family rich in present-day London. This is a fun adaptation, if “fun adaptation” is a thing you can say about a play soaked in grief and that notoriously features the deaths of pretty much every major character. This isn’t the Baz Luhrmann Romeo + Juliet approach; it’s just a really solid retelling done in a way that, as with The Odyssey, highlights the timelessness of the story.
Riz Ahmed is fully believable as someone who is in the “still figuring it out” phase of his life and doesn’t quite have the maturity at first to know what to do with the information that his uncle was the one who killed his father before nearly immediately marrying his mother. Ahmed also does a good job of making the “whether tis nobler in the mind” of it all feel like natural dialogue and thought, especially for someone addled with grief and anger. Chaddha is equally skilled at delivering Gertrude’s lines in a way that suggests layers of meaning. Gertrude gives Hamlet a look when Claudius is explaining that they are getting married that seems to convey a whole backstory about what is happening and about what she hopes Hamlet understands.
Featured photo: The Odyssey.
