With the restart of baseball set to go as the All-Star break ends, it’s time to hand out grades for the first half of this surprising Red Sox season. We’ll focus on key players or important parts of the team to start and leave the grades for the team and general manager until last.
Alex Cora: A+ The way he babies the pitchers still makes me crazy, but with him back in charge the karma seems so comfortable, which reduces angst when things are going bad for individuals, and that seems to make it easier for the team to do its job. If he’s not the best manager in baseball he’s darn close.
Middle of the Order: A With Xander Bogaerts, Rafael Devers and JD Martinez all deserving All-Stars they’ve done what was needed. Their projected numbers over 162 games gives context to the season each is having: Bogey .332, 26 (homers) and 97 (RBI), Raffy .282. 40 and 128, JD .299, 32, 110.
Matt Barnes: A Thanks to whoever convinced him to challenge hitters from the first pitch my frustration level from watching him pitch has dropped by about three area codes. It’s turned him from a guy with tantalizing stuff who constantly made his job harder into an All-Star closer and the best pitcher on the team.
Nate Eovaldi: A- The brass took a lot of flak for spending big after his solid post season of 2018 and with him winning just six games since then it was justified. But by going 9-5 he has stepped up to be the ace the Sox needed without Chris Sale and through Eduardo Rodriguez’s struggles. So bravo for that, but as the question always is for him, will it continue all year?
The Bullpen Overall: B How many times have we seen a starter come out in the fifth followed by the pen putting up doughnuts to close out a win? A lot more than most thought, and that’s particularly important with Cora yanking his untested or less trusted starter regularly in the fifth or sixth because of his trust in the pen.
Bargain Basement/Reclamation Pickups: B When Hunter Renfroe, Christian Arroyo and Kiké Hernández signed it didn’t make a ripple. In fact, it amplified the Tampa Bay North vibe growing since Chaim Bloom left TB to be Sox GM. But the first two have made positive if unspectacular contributions, while the $3 million per Renfroe has been solid offensively since May 1 and leads baseball in outfield assists. Plus while everyone from the defensively versatile bench is hitting around the Mendozza line, Marwin Gonzalez and company have had their moments. And let’s not forget Garrett Whitlock, whom Bloom took off the Yankees’ hands for pennies before he delivered a 3-1, 1.44 ERA season as a major bullpen contributor.
Alex Verdugo: C+ The prize (outside of the payroll flexibility gained) from the Mookie Betts trade has been very good defensively, but at .273 and his 9 homers and 31 RBI in 304 at-bats he’s projecting to just 16 and 55 over 162 games, so the offense hasn’t met expectations.
The Defense: C It’s shaky in spots, which can hurt when the margin of error gets tighter in big games. But shortstop and catcher (on offense as well) are solid and the outfield, where Verdugo’s versatility gives Cora options, throws people out trying to get the extra base better than almost everyone. Not great, but probably good enough to let them get by.
E-Rod: C- I proclaimed after the first month he was none the worse for missing all last year. Well, I was wrong. He’s been horrible at times, as evidenced by the team’s losing all five of his May starts, and inconsistent at others, as they then won all five June starts, though they had to score 12, 10 and 8 runs twice to do it. History says he’ll probably turn it around, but as of now the 5.52 ERA doesn’t make it.
Bobby Dalbec: C- With him hitting .191 against right-handed pitching and on track to strike out nearly 200 times he hasn’t been as solid as last year’s 28-game debut suggested he might be. Still he’s on track for 20 homers and 70 RBI, so maybe he’ll pick it up as the rookie adjustments continue.
End of the Bullpen: C- While the ERA’s of Darwinzon Hernandez (2.70) and Hirokazu Sawamura (2.45) are respectable, their 1.227 and 1.50 WHIPS give no confidence they’ll throw strikes when it counts. Then there is Matt Andriese with the unsightly 6.05 ERA, 1.768 WHIP and team-leading 7 homers (tied with Sawamura) allowed in just 30 innings. They need improvement in two spots at least.
Chaim Bloom: B While the early returns from bargain pick-up making significant contributions are encouraging, what he does to help the team fill in the holes at the trade deadline will determine the year’s final grade. So the question is with need for a lefty hitter, two bullpen slots and probably a starter (though Sale’s return could be that) will he let all that slide in a bid to keep all his minor-league assets intact or smartly determine who the keepers are and use the rest to fill his holes as best he can?
The Team: A Overall they are flawed, entered the break after losing four of their last six and despite solid work from Eovaldi and Nick Pivetta in particular, I’m still not certain about the starters. But against all odds they’re tied with Houston for the most wins in the league, lead the AL East by a game and a half over Tampa Bay, are eight ahead of the Yankees and on pace to win 97 games. And while in the words of Bloom they have not accomplished anything yet, it’s hard to find fault with a team that has exceeded even the wildest expectations so far.