The Wrong Hill to Die On is right for laughs
On an upcoming evening at Shaskeen Pub in Manchester, The Wrong Hill To Die On will feature a group of local comedians engaging in a kind of extreme debate, as they defend ridiculous premises, such as “traffic lights are a form of communist mind control.”
The event is hosted by self-described “open mic level comics” Nick Sands and Alex LaChance, with a panel of contestants that includes comics Matt Barry, Mona Forgione, Zach Remi and Tristen Hoffler. Derek Zeiba will open the show with a set, and comedian Ken Murphy will serve as a guest host.
Sands and LaChance are both fans of Story Warz, a weekly game show-themed event in New York City hosted by Luis J. Gomez and Big Jay Oakerson. They wanted to do something similar, but different from that show’s “guess who’s telling this tale” format.
“If you go back to the ’80s, when I was growing up, there were a hundred game shows on TV and half of them were rip-offs of other game shows,” LaChance said by phone recently. “So Wrong Hill To Die On is a kind of homage to that era, but also influenced by current comedy.”
Though LaChance and Sands are relatively new to standup, they’re both comfortable in front of audiences. Sands has a background in theater, LaChance spent two decades fronting rock bands, a few of which appeared at the Shaskeen, and both host podcasts. It’s new territory, but the two believe they have the tools to make it work.
Choosing topics, though, was a tricky proposition.“We didn’t want to put any comic in a position where they were defending something truly reprehensible, especially where we’re going to record it and put it out as a podcast, [so] what topics can we approach?” LaChance said.
In his final podcast of 2025, Nick Sands offered one position, that a McDonald’s burger tops anything on a holiday table. LaChance suggested another two: the casino age should be lowered to 10, and ducks should be allowed to go to school. “They range from silly to sexual in nature,” LaChance said. “I just don’t want to give them away.”
None of those will be used in the game, which will start with solo rants from each of the four competing comics, Barry, Forgione, Remi and Hoffler, with the panel — LaChance, Sands and Murphy — arguing back after each. Audience cheers decide who did the best job of defending the indefensible, and one comic will be eliminated at the end.
Round 2 is Audience Firestorm, where audience submissions are pulled at random; each comic has 30 to 45 seconds to defend them, culminating with another comic eliminated by applause. Finally, in Round 3, the remaining two comics are paired with two crowd members for tag team arguing, punctuated by occasional panelist interruptions.
A Lightning Inferno final round happens after the top comic is crowned. The winner will receive five to six “hot takes” to defend for 20 to 30 seconds each. The night ends with the winner receiving what’s promised as “a super-secret but very enticing prize.”
LaChance and Sands hope for continued success with the format; that’s one of the reasons they chose Shaskeen Pub as a venue, even though they make the rounds at several area comedy spots. In fact, LaChance announced a few days ago that he’s launching a Tuesday night open mic at The Moka Pot Café in Manchester, beginning Feb. 3.
“Nick was just at my house, and we were talking about it, and he said, ‘Do we want to keep doing it every year?’ and ‘I’m like, ‘If it works, I say we keep doing it,’” LaChance said. “I think being able to just have the same environment, just keep dialing it in, is going to make it better and better.”
The Wrong Hill to Die On
When: Tuesday, Jan. 20, at 8 p.m.
Where: Shaskeen Pub, 909 Elm St., Manchester
Tickets: $7.18 at eventbrite.com
Featured photo: Matt Barry. Courtesy photo.
